Blog Archives

A post by Peter Slutsky

Plagiarized? Nah.

I was away this weekend in beautiful Stanley, Virginia, celebrating my upcoming 27th birthday with a bunch of great friends. While I was comfortably nestled in the supple bosom of the Blue Ridge Mountains, the political dirt was flying fierce between the Clinton and Obama camps.

For those of you not following the story, the Clinton campaign has accused Obama of plagiarizing parts of a speech that he gave over the weekend in Wisconsin. In the speech, he used similar language to that of his good friend, supporter and main surrogate Deval Patrick of Massachusetts. Patrick has been all over the TV defending Obama and from what I can gather from the news shows this morning, most people in the media believe that this story is simply a last-ditch effort to try and take down Obama in advance of tonight’s primary. The only people who really think this is a story are the Clintons and their press people.

DoubleSpeak has not publicly endorsed a candidate and I haven’t written much about the day-to-day attacks and charges between the two camps. However, this one struck a nerve.

My boss, Mike Lux wrote up a piece on OpenLeft.com which is worth reading. Mike is a former Clinton Administration official.

Below is a blog post written by former Bill Clinton speechwriter David Kusnet from The New Republic blog, The Plank. It is an important piece and it should hopefully help to put this cooked-up scandal to rest.

Former Clinton Speechwriter Weighs In On Plagiarism-Gate

Barack Obama’s greatest strength is the originality of his rhetoric. Sometimes he talks like a regular person, as in his keynote address at the 2004 Democratic National Convention, when he introduced himself as “a skinny kid with a funny name.” Sometimes, he sounds like a president from an earlier, more historically literate era, as when he situates his campaign in a tradition that includes the American Revolution, the abolitionists, and the emergence of the labor movement, the civil rights movement, and other social struggles. But only rarely, if ever, does he use the familiar freeze-dried phrases that most current politicians favor. To borrow a phrase from the UAW, the “domestic content” of his speeches is unusually high.

That’s only one of many reasons why it’s so silly to accuse Obama of plagiarism because he used some of the same phrases as his friend and ally, Massachusetts Governor Deval Patrick (who, I should add, was helpful to me when he was assistant attorney general for civil rights at the same time I was a speechwriter for President Bill Clinton). If plagiarism is borrowing rhetoric without permission, Patrick most likely is happy to have Obama sound similar notes, such as hope and inspiration being more than “just words.” Even if Obama and Patrick didn’t know each other, they might use some of the same phrases because similar public figures frequently draw on common streams of public rhetoric. For instance, labor leaders often echo Walter Reuther or A. Philip Randolph; civil rights leaders draw upon the same scriptural passages and historical sources; and conservative Republicans repeatedly invoke Ronald Reagan. Similarly, John Edwards borrowed a rhetorical technique from his campaign manager, fellow populist and former Michigan congressman, David Bonior: His litany would begin “Somewhere in America,” and then he’d describe a social or economic injustice, such as a worker losing his job and his family’s health insurance. While Politico ran a story about this, it is hardly unusual for a candidate to share a rhetorical technique with his leading adviser.

After all, if there is one sentence from Scripture that is literally true, it is this line from Ecclesiastes: “There is nothing new under the Sun.” To be condemned as plagiarism, a political speech needs to be grievously offensive–using lots of distinctive but little-known material from another source without attributing it to that speaker or receiving his or her permission. For instance, in 1987, Joe Biden once used, without attribution, a speech by the British Labor Party Leader Neil Kinnock, in which Kinnock credited social programs with the fact that he was the first in his family to have attended college. By borrowing the speech and inserting his own name, Biden suggested that the men in his family had been coal miners when, in fact, as Maureen Down dryly noted, his father had been an auto dealer. (In fairness, Biden had quoted Kinnock when he had given the speech on other occasions.) Does what Obama did come close to what Biden did? Absolutely not. Next scandal, please.

–David Kusnet

UPDATE: Hillary Clinton is “Fired Up and Ready to Go!”

Willard “Mitt” Romney

is said to be quitting his campaign for the presidency. Developing…

A post by Peter Slutsky

Dennis Kucinich Abandons White House Bid

Openers blog, the political blog for the Cleveland Plain Dealer is reporting that Ohio Rep. Dennis Kucinich will drop out of the race for the White House.

Here is video of the announcement.

For more coverage of Dennis Kucinich, go to the Openers blog.

While most politicians cite “spending more time with their family” as the reason why they give up their political aspirations, in Dennis’s case, spending more time with his wife probably is (and should be) the actual reason. Oh, how I miss the sites in New Hampshire.

Elizabeth Kucinich

Former Governor

Mitt Romney has won the Michigan primary with 39%. Sen. John McCain has placed second with 30% and Mike Huckabee has come in third with 16% of the vote. CNN results can be found here.

A post by Peter Slutsky

Manchester, NH: Where Snowmen Come To Die…

A post by Peter Slutsky

Bob Novak To DoubleSpeak: ‘I Don’t Talk To The Huffington Post’

We ran into Bob Novak last week in New Hampshire and he made it very clear that he didn’t want to answer our questions. Check out the video.

A post by Peter Slutsky

Democrats For Romney

This is funny:

A post by Peter Slutsky

Democrats Tackle Faith

Monday night, CNN held a forum with John Edwards, Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton where they talked about the issues of faith and politics. I watched the forum on TV and thought that all three candidates articulated well their relationship with faith and religion and the role that both have played on their public and personal lives. The moderator, CNN’s Soledad O’Brien asked good questions and the panel of clergy, writers and leaders in the religious community did a good job of balancing their political views with their questions for the candidates. NPR has a good wrap up of the forum. Click on the image below to hear the radio broadcast.

NPR Faith Forum

A post by Peter Slutsky

Thompson Launches New Site

Former United States Senator Fred Thompson is ready to run for the GOP nomination. Today, he launched his “I’m With Fred” website. Click on the Thompson picture to view the site.

Thompson

Sen. Barack Obama

has just released his first quarter fundraising numbers. He has raised $25 million from over 100,000 individuals - just a little under what Sen. Hillary Clinton’s campaign raised in her first quarter. Read more here. The race is on!